Janácek - Sarka / Urbanová · Straka · Czech PO · Sir Charles Mackerras

On this CD:

1. Sárka, opera, JW 1/1
Composed by Leos Janacek
Performed by Czech Philharmonic Orchestra with Ivan Kusnjer, Peter Straka, Eva Urbanova
Conducted by Sir Charles Mackerras

Editorial Reviews
Amazon.com
Sárka was Janácek's first opera, discarded until the composer dug it out after the success of Jenufa, revised it, and had it performed in 1925. Janácek was fond of the work, but it fell into obscurity. One reason is its succinctness. Barely over an hour, the narrative is severely telescoped. Sárka, drawn from Czech mythology, is an Amazonian warrior, leader of a band of fierce women fighters ready to do battle with Ctirad, the tenor leader of their opponents. The protagonists meet, fall instantly in love, and just as instantly, Sárka sets a trap and her band beats Ctirad to death. Sárka then goes to the enemy camp and, distraught by her betrayal, commits suicide. Janácek's music here is more conventionally Romantic than it became, although hints of his later style peek through the revision. The opening instrumental prelude is lovely, but the drama is too abruptly sketched to create much involvement. Supraphon's team, though, makes a strong case for the work. Eva Urbanová, today's leading Czech soprano, is the star, and the others acquit themselves well. Sir Charles Mackerras and his crack orchestra are outstanding. Whatever its deficiencies as a stage work, this is an important release that enlarges our knowledge of the composer, making it a must-have for Janácek's growing army of admirers. --Dan Davis

Janácek - Sarka / Urbanová · Straka · Czech PO · Sir Charles Mackerras, Music, Leos Janácek, Sir Charles Mackerras, Eva Urbanova, Peter Straka, Czech Philharmonic Orchestra, Prague Philharmonic Choir, Ivan Kusnjer, Classical, Classical Music, Czech 20th/21st Century Opera, Opera, Opera / Operetta / Oratorio, Opera/Operetta

Janácek - Sarka / Urbanová · Straka · Czech PO · Sir Charles Mackerras
Average customer rating:

Another real discovery of Janacek's first opera.

Janácek - Sarka / Urbanová · Straka · Czech PO · Sir Charles Mackerras
Leos Janácek , Sir Charles Mackerras , Eva Urbanova , Peter Straka , Czech Philharmonic Orchestra , Prague Philharmonic Choir , and Ivan Kusnjer
Manufacturer: Supraphon
ProductGroup: Music
Binding: Audio CD

Janácek, Leos | ( J ) | Featured Composers, A-Z | Classical | Styles | Music
General | Classical | Styles | Music
General | Opera & Vocal | Styles | Music
Czech | Languages | Opera & Vocal | Styles | Music
Operettas | Opera & Vocal | Styles | Music
ASIN: B00005BGWK
Release Date: 2001-04-24

Amazon.com

Sárka was Janácek's first opera, discarded until the composer dug it out after the success of Jenufa, revised it, and had it performed in 1925. Janácek was fond of the work, but it fell into obscurity. One reason is its succinctness. Barely over an hour, the narrative is severely telescoped. Sárka, drawn from Czech mythology, is an Amazonian warrior, leader of a band of fierce women fighters ready to do battle with Ctirad, the tenor leader of their opponents. The protagonists meet, fall instantly in love, and just as instantly, Sárka sets a trap and her band beats Ctirad to death. Sárka then goes to the enemy camp and, distraught by her betrayal, commits suicide. Janácek's music here is more conventionally Romantic than it became, although hints of his later style peek through the revision. The opening instrumental prelude is lovely, but the drama is too abruptly sketched to create much involvement. Supraphon's team, though, makes a strong case for the work. Eva Urbanová, today's leading Czech soprano, is the star, and the others acquit themselves well. Sir Charles Mackerras and his crack orchestra are outstanding. Whatever its deficiencies as a stage work, this is an important release that enlarges our knowledge of the composer, making it a must-have for Janácek's growing army of admirers. --Dan Davis

Customer Reviews:

Another real discovery of Janacek's first opera........2001-05-29

In some ways Zdenek Fibich's Sarka (1896-1897) overshadows Janacek's opera of the same name. Written in 1887-1888, Janacek was more than proud of the work when he completed the piano score of it and in Alena Nemcova's well-written notes accompaning this CD, Janacek felt further encouraged after discussing the score with Antonin Dvorak. But Janacek ran into problems. The published text "Sarka, Musical Drama" was written by the poet Julius Zeyer and it was Zeyer who refused Janacek's request to set the text to music. After making further revisions and orchestrated the first two acts, Janacek put aside the score in his manuscript drawer, only to return to it in 1918. Once he returned to the score, he worked on it further and had his student, Osvald Chlubna complete the orchestration of Act III. At the end of 1918, the Czech Academy (to whom Zeyer had willed his rights) granted Janacek's request to use the text. Further revisions took place in 1924-1925 and the opera was performed posthumously, by 1938 in Olomouc, ten years after the composer's death.

Based on the Czech mythology as in Fibich's, Sarka is a Bohemian female warrior in Vlasta's women army and a follower of Libuse (a title name in Smetana's opera). After the death of Libuse, her husband, Prince Premysl expelled Sarka and her female companions from the court. Although not in Janacek's opera, Vlasta leads a revolt carried out by Sarka (having the tenacity and the daringness of a Brunnhilde or a Therese for that matter). Ctirad leads a male counter-revolution and guards Libuse's tomp. As the women attempt to capture the tomb, Ctirad repelled them. However, Ctirad fell in love with Sarka and although the feeling was mutual, she had him murdered by her cohorts. Driven by guilt, Sarka immolates herself on his funeral pyre.

The men versus women thing is certainly not "politically correct" for many. But, somehow I wish that Janacek had written a longer opera, for the story itself offers amble opportunities for theatrical presentations in huge scales and proportions as Fibich admirably proved: it could easily have been a grand opera in the vein of Gounod and Massenet. But Janacek was right to pursue the work despite the obstacles. His music is passionate, vivid, and heroic, absording much of Smetana as Fibich absorbed much of Wagner. But more importantly, for me at least, Janacek's Sarka have plenty of personal fingerprints to be found in his later works and his sense of dramatic impetus and musical incident is admirably established in his early endeavor.

Sir Charles Mackerras, to me the leading expert of Janacek's works, draws a forceful yet lucid performances from the Czech Philharmonic Orchestra and the Prague Philharmonic Choir. The casting is superb. Eva Urbanova could never have been a more powerful, compelling, visionary, Sarka. She portrayed Sarka with great tenacity as Birgit Nilsson did with Brunnhilde or Huguette Tourangeau with Therese (Massenet). Peter Straka brings out the heroics of Ctirad admirably and likewise with force while Ivan Kusnjer as Premysl and Jaroslav Brezina as Lumir are convincing throughout.

Before this recording, the first real discovery of Janacek's "flawed masterpiece" was the Multisonic mono (CD 310154-2) reissue of the 1953 recording featuring Brno Radio Symphony Orchestra and Chorus conducted by Bretislav Bakala (a best advocates of Janacek's music before Frantisek Jilek, Vaclav Neumann, and Mackerras). The casting is equally superb (Alena Novakova as Sarka is likewise thrilling) and the performance of the Brno Radio Symphony Orchestra and Chorus is compulsive in their own right.

Therefore, I would hunt for the Multisonic mono CD re-issue along with the Mackerras' Supraphon. One final note, though. It seems that Supraphon is, as of late, running a practice of not including a synopsis and/or detailed scenic discriptions within the libretti. That's a disadvantage to a listener who wants a more rounded picture of the plots behind the operas, especially those of obsurity such as Sarka and the Bride of Messina (of Fibich). Hopefully, Supraphon will reverse that and give us a fuller presentation as it did in its 1995 re-issue of Janacek's "Fate."

Nevertheless, a worthy acquisition along with the Multisonic mono reissue. Meanwhile, dare I hope for a revival of Janacek's Sarka in theatrical or in concert form?

Music Track:

Music Track

music track

Recommended Music:

Nightcombers [Import]

The Poetess Sings

Suites Pour Viole Seule & Concerts

Music: It's Too Late [CD-single] [Import]

The Ultimate Collected Spoken Words: 1967-1970 [Import]

Undone

The Powerpuff Girls: Power Pop [Enhanced]

The Green CD: Environmentally Friendly Australian Choral Music

Tuff and Stringy Sessions 1966-68

The Stage Door Swings

The Sweetest Punch: Songs Of Elvis Costello And Burt Bacharach

Touching Air [Live]

Thistle [Import]

French & German Flute Masterpieces

Is My Living in Vain?